Strange as it may seem considering the hype beforehand over “emotional Springbok swansongs” in the bronze playoff match at Rugby World Cup 2015, only 1 member of the squad at the tournament, captain Jean de Villiers, has officially confirmed his Test retirement.
Several younger Springboks spoke beforehand of their desire to beat Argentina – a task duly achieved – as a fitting send-off for senior players bidding farewell to the green-and-gold cause.
Almost 2 weeks on from the end of the Rugby World Cup, however, it is still only the luckless Jean de Villiers, injured again in just the 2nd Rugby World Cup match against Samoa, who has definitely bowed out after 109 appearances since 2002.
Perhaps influenced by the state of flux surrounding embattled coach Heyneke Meyer, the likes of Victor Matfield, Fourie du Preez, Schalk Burger and Bryan Habana intriguingly haven’t yet pulled the plug publicly on their illustrious Springbok careers.
The majority of “older” Springboks who took part in their hot-and-cold Rugby World Cup 2015 campaign are now exclusively foreign-based and there have been some pleas back home for only locally-stationed players to be chosen for South Africa henceforth – a tricky matter considering the ever-shrinking strength of the Rand against other currencies, which hardly helps keeps the best players rooted here.
Excluding Japanese Top League representatives Schalk Burger and JP Pietersen, who still have expected Super Rugby loyalties to the DHL Stormers and Cell C Sharks respectively in 2016, here is a player-by-player assessment of the possible, ongoing value to the Springbok cause of now fully overseas-contracted members of the recent Rugby World Cup squad:
Victor Matfield (Northampton Saints, age 38):
There’s a bit of a giggle on the rugby grapevine that Big Vic might have a 5th World Cup stab in 2019 … aged 42! You have to assume it is no more than a joke, don’t you? It is true that the lock likes of Brad Thorn (New Zealand) and Simon Shaw (England) played franchise rugby to around 40, but their Test careers had firmly ended by then. The rise of Eben Etzebeth and Lood de Jager means the door really ought to be locked now to Matfield at SA level, after a record 127 caps.
Verdict: Past Bok sell-by date.
Schalk Brits (Saracens, age 34):
Still looked a livewire in occasional Rugby World Cup exposure, in fairness. But the Springboks have to start looking to the long-term future in the berth, whilst the present still looks pretty assured in the hands of Bismarck du Plessis (see below) and Adriaan Strauss.
Verdict: Past Bok sell-by date.
Fourie du Preez (Suntory Sungoliath, age 33):
Came within whisker of confirming retirement after his facial knock in the Rugby World Cup semifinal against New Zealand, saying it was “likely” he’d played his last Springbok game. Perhaps had to be patched up more than we realise to play the tournament, yet managed to still look a class act. Bit of a concern that younger No 9s in SA still seem so far behind him.
Verdict: At Bok sell-by date … OK, almost.
Bryan Habana (Toulon, age 32):
Forgettable closing game against Los Pumas, but otherwise a sprightly, alert and industrious presence throughout the Rugby World Cup. Having a crack now at SA Sevens role in Olympics, though hinted heavily during Rugby World Cup that his Springbok hunger remains.
Verdict: Perhaps another 2 productive Springbok years?
Jannie du Plessis (Montpellier, age 32):
Little doubt now that Frans Malherbe, some 8 years his junior, has seized pole position in the Springbok tighthead battle. There are other promising ones on the rise domestically, but if Malherbe were to go down injured during Test season next year, Jannie du Plessis still shapes as a pretty comforting alternative; had spells of really good rugby in 2015.
Verdict: Not quite at Bok sell-by date.
Bismarck du Plessis (Montpellier, age 31):
Has just completed a year (and a Rugby World Cup) in which he remained a little short of his best known levels, but is still a class act and revered physical presence in the Springbok side. An example of the type of experience the team will still need, moving forward.
Verdict: Still chance of reaching Rugby World Cup 2019.
Willem Alberts (Stade Francais, age 31):
Has just begun a 3-year deal with the French club, pretty much confirming end of his Super Rugby life in SA. Don’t totally write off any ongoing Springbok involvement, especially if there are sudden mass casualties at loose forward in 2016, but the Bone Collector will probably only get more injury-prone himself with advancing age, and SA is traditionally blessed with great loosie depth.
Verdict: Past Springbok sell-by date.
Ruan Pienaar (Ulster, age 31):
Simply, not enough of a game-breaker on the evidence of the latest Rugby World Cup, and also a bit before it. Stays a popular presence at his Irish club, where his game is well-suited, but you have to think it’s end of the Springbok road for him after 88 appearances.
Verdict: Past Springbok sell-by date.
Morné Steyn (Stade Francais, age 31):
Two players suggest he has also had his Springbok swansong: Handré Pollard and Pat Lambie. Both pivots are considerably younger than the metronomic place-kicker, and potentially with their best years not yet witnessed. Their greater all-round abilities will be vital if the Springboks are to find a brave new way of playing.
Verdict: Past Springbok sell-by date.
Zane Kirchner (Leinster, age 31):
Like Steyn, considered a fairly robotic rugby player – efficiency hugely eclipsing any X-factor – and debatable presence in Meyer’s Rugby World Cup 2015 squad. Hard to see him being summoned from afar for the Springboks next year. It’s time the national side began examining the credentials of exciting rookies like the Bulls’ fleet-footed 20-year-old Warrick Gelant, and the lightweight but often devastating Cheslin Kolbe.
Verdict: Past Springbok sell-by date.
Francois Louw (Bath, age 30):
Among the premier turnover engineers at the Rugby World Cup, the English Premiership and ex-Stormers star did more than enough to suggest he wants to add significantly to his 43 Test caps. A possible Springbok captain from 2016, too…
Verdict: Still chance of reaching Rugby World Cup 2019.
Duane Vermeulen (Toulon, age 29):
After some 7 yeoman years at Newlands, the strapping No 8 embarks on a fresh club challenge in France. But he will remain one of the most desirable, indispensible Springbok call-ups from foreign climes, of that you can be sure.
Verdict: Still fresh, very influential and should go through to 1 more Rugby World Cup.
Sport24
Interesting article… by Sport 24…
There are 3 players in the bunch who could really still add value to the Springbok cause, namely Duane Vermeulen, Francois Louw and Bismarck du Plessis.
But if a decision has to be taken that only locally based players would be selected for the Springboks, then I think we can live without them too.
Duane Vermeulen is probably most difficult to replace, but there are alternatives at loose forward – Jaco Kriel at the Lions able to play both Openside and Blindside flank , Marcell Coetzee at the Cell C Sharks, Lappies Labuschagne at the Bulls, Nizaam Carr, Boom Prinsloo (effectively replacing the need for Francois Louw).
Bismarck, considering he has not been at his best, could also soon be replaced by the likes of Malcolm Marx or Robbie Coetzee or Scarra Ntubeni. The cupboard is not bare at hooker inside SA.
My plea is now for the Springboks to only make use of overseas-based players in case of dire emergency and not as a rule of thumb.
I am surprized this Article did not get more comments.
Users Online
Total 242 users including 0 member, 242 guests, 0 bot online
Most users ever online were 3735, on 31 August 2022 @ 6:23 pm